Very quick review.

Of course more randomization more Dark Souls bosses more general ER bosses would be nice.
SOTE weapons and spells hopefully gets added later that will add a lot of new randomization.

New map is good first few runs of course hard, you need to get used to the map that yo ucant just aimlessly run around you have to look up and down a bit (which is bit harder with controller).
After a few runs map is managable, you just have to keep track of crystals around you and go there break them during runs, search for them or just use a guide if you dont care they are always at the same place.

And of course 3 insetad of 2 new bosses would have been better but they went more qualiyty > quantity here.
If I would have been a dev I would have added at elast 1 new skin to already existing nightfearers. (Community has a lot of good ideas for old DS skins just add one of those show the "old" nightfearer mains some love.)

Game has a lot of potention still for at least 2 more DLC but they need to add a lot of random stuff, also would love full random boss pool, what I mean by this they need to not limit the Day1 / Day2 bosses to one nightlord, make them fully random (even if only in DoN its fine).

First time Soulslike players downvoting the DLC because "Scadutree fragment balance and its too hard". Its not a boss rush game go explore take your time.

DLC is just as good as base game most fun weapons coming from it and memorable new bosses. Maybe slight performance issues (like avarage -5 maybe -10 FPS compared to basegame but Nvidia drivers already almost fixed it and later furutre patches most likely will)

Closest we have ever been to a game that could easily be Portal 3.

- Custom voice lines.
- New story that connects to the old games.
- New portal puzzle pieces.
- New engine which looks really good.

Trust me just buy the damn game.
Hours and hours of fun gameplay.