CreampieCathy: There's a lot to like about a depraved, highly sexual film that appeals to the basic human desire to shoot sperm into a woman. I also like the title of the act. Nakadashi is one of the nastiest acts outside of fetish movies, but it sounds noble. Creampie Cathy sounds like an artisanal baker, but of course we know better.

CreampieCathy.com has been selling amateur cream pie since 1998, which is a classic in itself. The site was founded by the illustrious Kathy, who calls herself "the undisputed queen of debauchery." According to the site's statistics, this woman has received more than 10,000 "creams" from more than 4,300 men. In the years since the site began, she has gone from MILF to MILF, but is now bringing a whole new generation of sluts into the game.

Over 20 years of amateur Creampies.

Not surprisingly, Creampie Cathy's layout is a bit dated -- it's been around for over 20 years and has always been an amateur site. The color scheme is ugly, but the screenshots won't keep you looking at the design for long. At the top of the screen, large shots from recent movies appear. We see Cassie being gang-raped and stretched out with two cocks in her pussy, and her girlfriends joining in the act. Some of the women drink cum from other women's clamps, a degree of depravity I'd like to see at every opportunity.

Creampie Cathy's other claim to fame is that she is the largest solo amateur site. There's no doubt she's top-notch, but she's certainly helped immensely by a rotation of hot amateur teens, MILFs and everything in between. About half of the thumbnails are of other girls having threesomes with Cassie or coming to Nakadashi's party. On some of the thumbnails, the CreampieCathy name doesn't appear at all, even in the moving previews.

These moving GIFs are the closest thing to a free video on the tour page, but I like what I see." The word "amateur" is a very complicated term in pornography. On the one hand, there's the obvious "handmade" iPhone video, a 12-second piece of shaky sex. On the other, there's fake porn where the cameraman just happens to meet an incredibly beautiful woman who just lost her dog and enjoys doing anal licking. CreampieCathy is somewhere in the middle, combining amateurish rawness with more than 20 years of experience making home-made sex movies.

The lack of excessive sophistication also contributes to the film's atmosphere: even in front of the GIFs, you feel like you're in for an almost unplanned sex party. It's like you're lucky enough to find a bunch of hot, horny women and a photographer who knows how to shoot group sex in a hot tub and lesbian intergenerational bonding.

Cheaper and with a richer selection than the cream pie at Costco

What makes up for this slightly disappointing old-fashioned layout are the old-fashioned prices - CreampieCathy.com doesn't seem to have updated its prices one bit, as a regular membership costs $25 a month. That's a few dollars less than most 2022 sites, and a lot less if you sign up for a longer term.

It's nice to see that they haven't updated their prices in a while and that they are constantly updating their site. They add a full amateur Nakadashi exclusive video every week. It's a good thing Cassie is old, otherwise she would be pregnant all the time and her other children would go to Planned Parenthood.

I told you that this site has been around for over 20 years. Even if you took a math class, you would already know that its release schedule adds up. The library seems endless, with cum-filled cunts flowing down the corridors of history.

The CreampieCathy archive alone is huge, but over the years we've managed to build relationships with many friends and affiliate sites. As a member, you get access to many bonus sites and additional movies. Most of these are top-notch amateur content, matching Creampie Cathy's level of production and fapability.

For $25 a month, you can enjoy more than 2,000 amateur videos. Sure, those creamy peas won't feed your family, but it's a solid deal for a good homemade dessert.

Professional amateur content in 4K UHD resolution

With such a large selection, I decided to start at the beginning and watch them in order.The latest CreampieCathy video - Scene 718: Fallon's Creampie GB - p1. I'm guessing from the thumbnail that GB means "gang bang" - it was uploaded on April 20, so I put some Viagras in the bong in honor of Kathy.

When I click on the video page, her outdated layout follows me.These days, most sites present movies upside down with a big built-in video player; CreampieCathy uses the old design where you have to scroll down to find the video link next to the photo gallery. I realize that this only adds a few seconds to the time it takes to watch an amateur two-hole introduction scene, but it seems too inefficient. Old people who pay their dues by check should feel right at home.

The good news is that at least they're using the latest video formats -- CreampieCathy.com now publishes movies in gloriously realistic 4K Ultra HD. Many major premium sites are still in the process of transitioning from 1080p, so you have to appreciate that Cathy is on the cutting edge of technology, at least where it really matters.

The movies are direct links, so you can open them in a browser or right-click to save. Downloads are available at no extra charge, which is also welcome.

Quirky group sex with quirky girls.

The scene opens with Creampie Cathy bouncing on a hotel bed. She chats with the black gentlemen around her and starts making out with a pretty Ukrainian girl named Fallon; by the time her boobs show up at the minute mark, they are surrounded by a whole room of guys, all of them already horny.

I love that they don't waste any time. There are two women, six men, and just over half an hour, so I can see why they're in a hurry: by two minutes each woman has her dick in her mouth and in her hand; by three minutes Fallon is riding a man's face, sucking another man's dick; by four minutes she has her dick in her mouth and another in her hand.

I'm a little infatuated with this woman, Fallon. She's beautiful, enthusiastic, and talented. She's practically an amateur, but I assume this is her first time satisfying a partner. She is completely in her element, seems to enjoy herself and is not at all overwhelmed by the onslaught of an absolute cock. Look at the smile on her face as one man fucks her pussy and the other two put their cocks in her face.

She probably learned it from her mentor. Katie is one of the most erotic old women I've seen in pornography in a long time. The camera mostly focuses on the young Euro chick, but every time I see Katie, she turns her attention to her big cock. It is this attitude that has kept this site going for so long.

The site says that "Creampie Cathy demands that all cum be injected into her vagina." That's exactly how it ends, but that's also part of its charm. "Fallon's 1st Creampie GB - p1" does not disappoint in this work.

The site has been around for a long time because it offers a real amateur look into the lives of real nymphomaniacs and their friends, and Kathy is a cum lover to the core and doesn't seem to have lost the enthusiasm with which she started the site. Death is raw and sexy, updates are frequent, and a huge amount of bonus material is available for users. Fans of depraved DIY breeding movies will love this.