I've got an interactive fiction collection on my profile with my favourite itchio IFs if you want to take a look! Also if you want some supernatural IF recs specifically:

Ongoing series:

• The Wayhaven Chronicles
• Blood Moon

Standalone completed games:

• The Fog Knows Your Name
• The Passenger
• Donor

WIPs:

• Demonology: Incubus
• We Wretched Creatures
• The Second Sight
• God Cursed
• Corruptant
• Children of Cain
• Unsanctioned
• Within Your Eyes
• Disenchanted