This Group is about finding out if an MMO is worth while, and NOT pay to win!
(with exceptions)

Criteria:

Gameplay: 0-10. If a game can't be played, it should NOT be worth money.

Graphics: 0-5. At least playable graphics should exist in an mmo.

End-Game Content: 0-1. You could look this up if you don't have time to hit max level. Just take impression from user reviews on websites, forums, or steam store page, if the endgame content is existant, and GOOD, then give it a 1.


Bugs or Glitches: 0 to -10. Negative means loads of bugs and glitches. Certain glitches lead to exploitation, and bugs lead to mad fans, you wouldn't want that in a community based game.


NOT PAY TO WIN: 0-1. If it's pay to win, it has a store, and they sell endgame stuff, but that means nobody plays your game. But in their mind, they expect people to purchase these things once, and think they'll get addicted. Quite the opposite ensues actually.


Pay to Play: 0-1. This isn't as BIG of a problem as P2W, but it still might hurt the game's population.


Leveling Zones: 0-10. These are important, they need to hold variety, but not to much variety that nothing feels like the same game, if you can create a desert zone, than you should have the same tools for other types of flooring.


NPC Scaling: 0-10. If the npcs are well scaled for the zones they inhabit, if they are to powerful the zone is useless to the player-base, if they are to weak for the zone, then they are just a free level to 5 levels.



Good Button Allocation: 0-1. If you are able to press buttons while moving without stretching your hand like a Parkensons patient, then good for the game.